DDTC Imposes $1 Million Penalty on German Company and U.S. Affiliate for ITAR Violations
The State Department's Directorate of Defense Trade Controls (DDTC) announced today that it entered into a consent agreement this week with Kaltenkirchen, Germany-based Interturbine Aviation Logistics GmbH, and its Grand Prairie Texas branch office, Interturbine Aviation Logistics GmbH, LLC, to resolve violations of the Arms Export Control Act (AECA) and International Traffic in Arms Regulations (ITAR) allegedly committed in 2004. The Interturbine companies are distributors of a wide range of products for the international commercial aviation sector.
This case marks the first penalty action taken by DDTC in 2010. It is widely expected that DDTC this year will conclude many more than the consent agreements that were finalized in 2009.
According to the Proposed Charging Letter, DDTC alleged that Interturbine committed seven violations of the ITAR associated with the unlicensed export to Germany of 400 kilograms of a heat resistant protective coating classified in USML Category IV(f) that can be used on missiles to protect high heat areas. The Proposed Charging Letter notes that even though the product was indicated in the company's inventory system as export controlled, some senior members of the company in Germany bypassed the company's normal procedures to order the product from its U.S. affiliate for shipment to a customer in Germany. After the product was shipped from Texas to Germany as NLR, the German customer later contacted Interturbine about the lack of an export license, suspended payment and quarantined the shipment. The material was subsequently returned to the U.S. and seized by U.S. Customs and Border Protection. A criminal investigation was then initiated by U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement.
Although the criminal case was later dropped as a result of the company's remedial measures, DDTC charged the company with one count of exporting the ITAR-controlled material to Germany without the proper license, one count of misrepresentation and omission of facts, two counts of willfully causing an unauthorized export, one count of exporting a defense article without being registered with DDTC, one count of failing to obtain a non-transfer and use certificate (DS-83) and one count of an unauthorized retransfer.
Under the consent agreement, Interturbine agreed to pay a civil penalty of $1,000,000, of which $900,000 will be suspended. DDTC agreed to suspend $500,000 of the penalty on the condition that Interturbine has already applied that amount to self-initiated, pre-consent agreement remedial compliance measures. In addition, $400,000 will be suspended on the condition that Interturbine maintains its self-initiated exclusion from all ITAR regulated activities.
If within the two-year term of this Consent Agreement Interturbine decides to become involved in ITAR regulated activities, Interturbine agreed to use this $400,000 for additional remedial compliance measures agreed to by the Department. Interturbine will also be subject to an independent audit to ensure that its company-wide Automated Export Control system prevents its involvement in all ITAR regulated activities and agreed to on-site reviews by DDTC.
DDTC also determined that an administrative debarment of Interturbine is not appropriate at this time since the company has already begun implementing the remedial compliance actions specified in this consent agreement.